Combating Alarm Fatigue: The Hidden Cause of Medical Errors & Malpractice
- EvaluCare
- May 26
- 7 min read
Updated: May 27
In today’s high‐tech hospitals, clinical alarms are everywhere: from beeping infusions and ventilator alerts to heart monitors and bedside telemetry. These alarms exist to keep patients safe, alerting clinicians to life‑threatening changes in vital signs, equipment malfunctions, or medication delivery errors. Yet, when alarms fire incessantly, often for non‑critical reasons, clinicians can become desensitized, leading to alarm fatigue, one of the most pressing patient safety risks in modern healthcare.
This blog explores the purpose and risks of clinical alarms, the Joint Commission’s National Patient Safety Goal on alarm management, relevant standards, key findings from the literature, and practical steps family members can take to ensure their loved ones’ alarms are respected and responded to.
Finally, we’ll explain how EvaluCare can help review medical records when alarm management failures may have contributed to patient harm.
The Purpose of Clinical Alarms
Clinical alarms serve as real‑time alerts to the care team when a patient’s condition deviates from preset safe limits or when critical equipment requires attention. Common alarm types include:
Physiologic alarms (e.g., heart rate too high/low, oxygen saturation drops)
Ventilator alarms (e.g., high airway pressure, low tidal volume)
Infusion pump alarms (e.g., occlusion, air-in-line)
Bed exit alarms (e.g., patient leaving bed unattended)
Door and cabinet alarms (e.g., controlled‐substance access)
By design, these alarms are calibrated to be immediately noticeable—both louder and more urgent than background noise—to prompt rapid intervention. In acute settings, every second counts, and alarms can mean the difference between timely treatment and irreversible decline.
When Alarms Backfire: The Phenomenon of Alarm Fatigue
What Is Alarm Fatigue?
Alarm fatigue occurs when clinicians are exposed to high volumes of alarms—many of which are non‑actionable or false positives—and begin to:
Ignore or silence alarms without assessing the patient
Delay response times to serious alarms
Disable alarms entirely, increasing risk of missed critical events
Studies identify alarm fatigue as a leading hazard: the ECRI Institute lists it among the top health technology safety risks, citing that nurses can experience hundreds of alarms per shift . In one ICU study, 70–99% of alarms were deemed false or clinically insignificant .
Consequences for Patient Safety
Missed Critical Events: Desensitized clinicians may delay or omit responding to genuine emergencies, leading to cardiac arrests, respiratory failure, or severe hypotension.
Sleep Disruption: Frequent nighttime alarms fragment patient sleep, impairing healing and contributing to delirium, especially in older adults.
Noise Pollution: High alarm volumes contribute to stressful environments for patients and families.
Workload Stress: Clinicians juggling multiple alarms face cognitive overload, increasing the risk of documentation errors and communication breakdowns.
The Joint Commission’s Alarm Safety Initiative
Recognizing alarm fatigue as a serious threat, The Joint Commission launched a National Patient Safety Goal (NPSG.06.01.01) focused on alarm management:
NPSG.06.01.01: Reduce the risk of harm associated with clinical alarm systems.
Key Requirements
Accredited hospitals must:
Establish Alarm Policies & Procedures
Define criteria for alarm settings, threshold values, and response protocols.
Maintain & Calibrate Equipment
Ensure alarms function correctly with scheduled maintenance and safety checks.
Customize Alarm Parameters
Tailor thresholds to individual patients, reducing false positives.
Train Staff
Educate clinicians on alarm technologies, proper use, and response expectations.
Monitor Compliance & Performance
Audit alarm response times, override rates, and incident reports to drive improvement.
Related Joint Commission Standards
EC.02.05.01: Medical equipment is maintained to ensure safe operation.
EM.02.01.01: Use alarms and alerts when needed to monitor risks.
By integrating these standards, hospitals create a structured approach to identify alarm hazards, implement controls, and evaluate effectiveness.
Quantifying the Alarm Burden
Critical Care Units A landmark study found 846 alarm signals per bed per day in ICUs, with nurses silencing up to 90% of alarms .
Step‑Down & Telemetry Units Over 40% of monitored patients experience clinically actionable arrhythmias, but high false alarm rates (often >50%) lead to frequent silencing.
Strategies to Mitigate Alarm Fatigue
Alarm Parameter Tuning
Widening thresholds for non‐critical parameters (e.g., SpO₂ alarms set to <88% rather than <92%) can cut non‑actionable alarms by 40–60%.
Multi‑Parameter Algorithms
Advanced monitors that integrate multiple vital signs reduce false alarms by requiring corroborating data before firing.
Wearable & Wireless Sensors
Reducing extraneous leads and cables decreases dislodgement‑triggered alarms.
Dedicated Alarm Response Teams
Having rapid response nurses triage and prioritize alarms offloads burdens from bedside clinicians.
What Family Members Can Do
Advocate for Proper Alarm Management
Ask About Alarm Policies
“Can you explain how my loved one’s alarms are set and who responds?”
Encourage Parameter Customization
If alarms are incessant, politely suggest discussing whether thresholds can be safely adjusted.
Understand Alarm Meanings
Request a brief explanation of common alarm tones and colors on your floor’s monitors.
Be a Safety Partner
Listen & Alert
If you hear repeated alarms, don’t assume “they know.” Press the call button or ask a nurse to verify.
Provide Context
Tell staff about your loved one’s baseline behaviors (e.g., “He often phones in low oxygen sat drops when he’s anxious; please check before silencing.”).
Support Sleep Hygiene
Work with nurses to cluster care activities, minimizing nighttime alarms.
Document Patterns
Note times when alarms go unanswered or cause distress—these observations can inform unit improvements.
When to Escalate Concerns
Delayed Response
If staff take longer than a few minutes to respond to a persistent alarm, escalate to nurse manager.
Disabled Alarms
If you notice alarms are turned off, ask politely why and ensure they are reinstated.
Frequent False Alarms
Share concerns about alarm fatigue during patient and family advisory council meetings or safety huddles.
Clinical Alarm Caes
Massachusetts General Hospital – Cardiac Monitor Alarm Silence
Settlement: $850,000
Overview: In 2011, a patient on a cardiac unit at Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) deteriorated overnight. The patient’s telemetry monitor repeatedly sounded alarms for bradycardia and asystole, but overwhelmed nursing staff, facing dozens of non‑actionable alarms each shift—failed to respond in time. By morning rounds, the patient had suffered irreversible brain injury, later dying from complications.
Outcome: In 2012, the patient’s family settled with MGH for $850,000. The lawsuit and subsequent media coverage (including reporting by The Boston Globe and CBS Boston) helped spark national attention on “alarm fatigue” and prompted MGH to overhaul its alarm management policies CBS NewsHealth Leaders Media.
Pennsylvania Ambulatory Surgery Center – Post‑Tonsillectomy Respiratory Monitor
Disabled
Award: $6 millionOverview: A 17‑year‑old underwent a routine tonsillectomy at a
Pennsylvania outpatient surgery center. Post‑operatively, she was placed on a respiratory monitor intended to alarm for apnea or hypoventilation. Staff found the device’s frequent alarms “annoying” and muted it. Approximately 25 minutes later, a respiratory arrest went unnoticed until the monitor was reactivated, by then, it was too late to reverse severe anoxic brain injury.Outcome: A jury awarded the family $6 million in 2013, finding that disabling the alarm constituted negligence. This case is frequently cited in the literature as a tragic exemplar of alarm fatigue. South Florida Injury Lawyer Blog.
Wrongful Death Lawsuit Alleges Alarm Fatigue – Pennsylvania Hospital
Status: Filed May 2023; damages pending
Overview: In May 2023, the estate of a hospitalized patient filed a wrongful death suit against a Pennsylvania hospital, alleging that repeated ventilator and cardiac alarms signaling respiratory distress were ignored by staff, an omission attributed to alarm fatigue. According to the complaint, the patient’s decline triggered dozens of alarms over several hours, but with insufficient staffing and high noise burdens, clinicians failed to assess or intervene.
Outcome: While this case is still pending, it underscores the ongoing legal risk: families are increasingly holding institutions accountable when alarm silencing or delayed responses contribute to death. Medical Malpractice Lawyers.
Why These Cases Matter
Multiple Safeguards Needed
Relying solely on alarm volume is insufficient, robust policies, parameter customization, and staff training are essential.
Regulatory Pressure
The Joint Commission’s NPSG.06.01.01 on alarm management is now a survey focus; non‑compliance can threaten accreditation.
Cultural Change
Hospitals must foster a “stop the line” mentality where every team member feels empowered to address alarm burdens and escalate risks.
Building an Alarm‑Safe Culture
To truly tackle alarm fatigue, hospitals must:
Engage Leadership
Allocate resources for alarm management committees and technology upgrades.
Empower Frontline Staff
Encourage nurses and aides to suggest parameter changes and report alarm hazards.
Partner with Families
Include patients and families in safety rounds focused on alarm burden.
Leverage Technology
Adopt centralized monitoring stations and mobile alerting to reduce bedside noise.
Continuous Monitoring & Feedback
Use dashboards to track alarm counts, response times, and staff feedback.
Conclusion
Clinical alarms are lifesavers when used correctly—but when left unchecked, they become a silent threat to patient safety. Alarm fatigue desensitizes care teams, masks genuine emergencies, and contributes to preventable harm. By understanding The Joint Commission’s National Patient Safety Goal on alarm management, embracing evidence‑based mitigation strategies, and empowering family members to speak up, hospitals can restore the balance between vigilance and noise.
If you suspect alarm failures contributed to your loved one’s injury or death, EvaluCare is here to help you navigate the complex clinical and technical issues involved. Together, we can ensure alarms fulfill their true purpose: protecting patients when every second counts.
When Alarm Failures Cause Harm: Turning to EvaluCare
If you suspect that ignored or disabled clinical alarms contributed to a loved one’s injury or death, EvaluCare can help by:
Reviewing Care and nursing documentation and staffing records and adverse event reporting records, and against accepted practice guidelines outlined by organizations like The Joint Commission and ECRI.
Patient and Family Member Experience is a key indicator of how clinicians respond.
Delivering Clear, Actionable Reports to support legal claims or drive institutional remediation to support patients with direct settlements
EvaluCare’s rigorous, multidisciplinary reviews shine a light on hidden failures, helping families seek accountability and healthcare organizations restore safety. Since we are healthcare insiders who have led projects to reduce alarm fatigue in hospitals, we know what alarms critical and what ones are often are ignored.
For more information or to request a medical care review, visit:EvaluCare Medical Care Review Services
---
References
The Joint Commission. National Patient Safety Goal NPSG.06.01.01: Improve the safety of clinical alarm systems. Joint Commission; 2024.
ECRI Institute. Top 10 Hospital Hazards for 2023: Alarm Fatigue. ECRI; 2023.
Cvach M. “Monitor alarm fatigue: an integrative review.” Biomed Instrum Technol. 2012;46(4):268–277.
Sendelbach S, Funk M. “Alarm fatigue: a patient safety concern.” AACN Adv Crit Care. 2013;24(4):378–386.
World Health Organization. WHO Patient Safety Curriculum Guide. WHO; 2011.
Comments