Surgical Malpractice: Common Issues, High-Risk Specialties, and How Patients Can Protect Themselves

Surgery can be high risk. Knowing the types of errors that can occur is a great first step in managing risk.

Surgery can be a crucial step toward healing, but it can come with potential life altering risks. While many procedures are performed safely, surgical malpractice remains a serious concern. Each year, thousands of patients suffer harm due to preventable surgical errors. From wrong-site surgeries to retained surgical instruments, these errors can have devastating and lasting consequences. Let’s explore  the most common issues leading to surgical malpractice, identify high-risk specialties, and provide actionable ways for patients and families to protect themselves.

Common Surgical Malpractice Issues

Medical malpractice in surgery can occur for various reasons, many of which are preventable. Below are the most frequently reported surgical errors and the contributing factors behind them:

1. Wrong-Site Surgery

Wrong-site surgery involves operating on the wrong part of the body, the wrong side, or even the wrong patient. This alarming error is considered a "never event," meaning it should never occur if appropriate safety protocols are followed. Causes include failure to verify patient information, mislabeling, and breakdowns in communication during surgical preparation and even miscommunication during surgery.

2. Wrong-Patient Surgeries

In rare but shocking cases, a patient may undergo a surgery intended for someone else. These incidents often arise from patient misidentification, documentation errors, or incorrect scheduling. Such errors emphasize the importance of thorough preoperative verification processes.

3. Surgical Errors

These errors range from accidental damage to organs and blood vessels to poor technique and inadequate closure. Even minor mistakes during surgery can lead to severe complications, longer recovery times, or the need for additional procedures. Many of these are attributed to inexperience, fatigue, or failure to adhere to standard procedures.

4. Retained Foreign Objects

Leaving surgical instruments, sponges, or other materials inside a patient after surgery is a grave and avoidable error. Retained foreign objects can cause infections, pain, and the need for further surgical intervention. The root cause is often failure to count instruments and tools before closing the surgical site.

5. Failure to Follow Protocols

Standardized surgical protocols exist to ensure patient safety. These include time-outs, surgical checklists, and infection prevention guidelines. When these protocols are ignored or inconsistently applied, the risk of complications rises significantly. Failure to follow protocols is often a systemic issue, indicating problems in the surgical team's culture or hospital management.

6. Post-Operative Complications

Complications such as infections, blood clots, and delayed healing can occur due to poor post-operative care. Factors contributing to these complications include inadequate monitoring, insufficient follow-up, inadequate prophylaxis care, and failure to educate patients about signs of infection or other issues.

7. Anesthesia Errors

Errors in administering anesthesia can lead to brain damage, cardiac arrest, or death. These errors may occur due to incorrect dosage, failure to recognize allergic reactions, or poor monitoring during surgery.

8. Inadequate Preoperative Evaluation

Failure to assess a patient’s medical history, allergies, or comorbid conditions can result in life-threatening outcomes. Informed consent must also be part of this process, ensuring patients understand all potential risks.

Causal Factors Behind Surgical Errors

Research and malpractice data consistently identify several root causes for surgical errors:

• Communication Failures: Miscommunication among surgical team members or between departments.

  
  

• Human Error: Fatigue, distraction, and inadequate training contribute to many preventable mistakes.

  
  

• Systemic Failures: Poor organizational policies, understaffing, and failure to implement safety protocols.

  
  

• Lack of Standardization: Inconsistent use of checklists or time-out procedures.

  
  

• Inadequate Supervision: Junior, resident surgeons operating without sufficient oversight.

  
  

High-Risk Specialties for Surgical Malpractice

Some surgical fields have higher rates of malpractice claims due to the complexity and risk involved:

1. Neurosurgery

Neurosurgeons deal with the brain and spinal cord, where even minor errors can lead to paralysis, cognitive impairments, or death. The stakes are incredibly high, making this specialty one of the most scrutinized.

2. General Surgery

This includes abdominal surgeries, appendectomies, and gallbladder removals. Due to the volume of procedures and varying complexity, general surgery is prone to complications like bleeding, infection, or organ damage.

3. Orthopedic Surgery

Orthopedic surgeons operate on bones, joints, and muscles. Mistakes can lead to chronic pain, mobility issues, or the need for corrective surgeries. Joint replacements and spinal surgeries are particularly high-risk.

How Patients and Families Can Protect Themselves

While hospitals and surgeons bear the primary responsibility for safety, patients and their families can take several steps to minimize risk and advocate for their care.

1. Choose High-Performing Hospitals

Not all hospitals are equal. Look for institutions that specialize in the procedure you need and have high patient satisfaction and safety scores. Websites like Medicare’s Hospital Compare or independent hospital rating systems (e.g., U.S. News & World Report) can help identify top performers.

2. Vet the Surgeon’s Experience

Ensure your surgeon has extensive experience with your specific procedure. Ask how many times they have performed it, what their complication rates are, and whether they are board-certified in their specialty.

3. Understand Informed Consent

Don’t sign consent forms without fully understanding the procedure, alternatives, risks, and expected outcomes. Ask questions until you feel comfortable. You have the right to know everything that could go wrong, even if the risks are small. Ask the surgeon how many of their patients experience the listed complications.

4. Recognize Early Signs of Complications

Patients should be informed about the warning signs of infections, bleeding, blood clots, and anesthesia issues. Promptly reporting symptoms like fever, severe pain, or shortness of breath can prevent complications from worsening.

5. Participate in Pre-Surgery Checklists

Many hospitals now involve patients in the preoperative verification process. Confirm your name, procedure, and surgical site with every provider you encounter. Don’t hesitate to speak up if something seems off.

6. Bring a Family Advocate

Having a family member or trusted friend accompany you before and after surgery ensures there is someone to monitor care, ask questions, and catch potential errors.

7. Follow Post-Op Instructions Closely

Strictly adhere to discharge instructions. Take medications as prescribed, attend all follow-up appointments, and avoid activities that could interfere with healing.

8. Report Concerns Promptly

If something feels wrong post-surgery, contact your healthcare provider immediately. Delays in addressing complications often result in more severe outcomes.

9. Request a Second Opinion

Especially for major surgeries, consider getting a second opinion. Another surgeon may offer a less invasive alternative or a different perspective on the risks involved.

Conclusion

Surgical malpractice, while often preventable, continues to be a leading cause of harm in the healthcare system. Understanding the common issues and causal factors allows patients and families to be better prepared. High-risk specialties such as neurosurgery, general surgery, and orthopedic surgery require particular vigilance.

By choosing experienced providers, participating in safety protocols, understanding informed consent, and monitoring for complications, patients can reduce their risk of becoming victims of surgical error. Empowered and informed patients and their family members or healthcare advocates are essential partners in the delivery of safe surgical care.

---

EvaluCare provides medical care review services for patients, families and attorneys. If you have concerns about the care you, a loved one or a client received, EvaluCare can arm victims with the knowledge they need to get the settlements they deserve. If you or a loved one needs medical care reviewed, email info@EvaluCare.net or visit EvaluCare.net